Information

Did Anita Sarkeesian fabricate her story about contacting the authorities?

Basic shortcuts

Ctrl + SSave subtitles
Ctrl + click
Double click
Edit highlighted caption
TabEdit next caption
Shift + TabEdit previous caption
EscLeave edit mode
Ctrl + SpacePlay / pause video
Ctrl + HomePlay selected caption
Ctrl + EnterSplit caption at cursor position
at current time

Advanced shortcuts

Ctrl + InsertAdd new caption
Ctrl + DeleteDelete selected caption
Ctrl + IEdit currently played segment
Shift + EnterNew line when editing
Ctrl + LeftPlay from -1s
Ctrl + RightPlay from +1s
Alt + LeftShift caption start time -0.1s
Alt + RightShift caption start time +0.1s
Alt + DownShift caption end time -0.1s
Alt + UpShift caption end time +0.1s

Annotation shortcuts

Ctrl + 1Hesitation
Ctrl + 2Speaker noise
Ctrl + 3Background noise
Ctrl + 4Unknown word
Ctrl + 5Wrong segment
Ctrl + 6Crosstalk segment
You are in the read-only mode. Close
00:18.9
00:20.9
Davis Aurini: Davis speaking.
00:21.0
00:24.8
Albie Esparza: Hi, this is Albie Esparza from San Francisco Police, how are you?
00:24.9
00:27.8
Aurini: Not doing too badly, yourself?
00:28.1
00:33.0
Esparza: Good. You left a message and so we're trying to see what it is that we can help you with.
00:33.1
00:35.9
Aurini: Yes, just give me a second, here.
00:37.9
00:42.1
Aurini: Alright, so I'm just trying to reset my brain right now.
00:43.5
00:47.8
Aurini: Davis Aurini, I'm a freelance writer/journalist/filmmaker.
00:47.9
00:51.9
Aurini: Could I just confirm you name again, as to who I'm speaking to?
00:53.0
00:54.9
Esparza: [UNKNOWN WORD] Esparza, what can we help you with?
00:55.0
01:00.6
Aurini: I’m calling about an incident which occurred in your district on the 26th of August.
01:00.7
01:07.1
It was to a Ms. Sarkeesian. She's a prominent cultural critic and she received a number of death threats over Twitter,
01:07.2
01:09.5
which wind [sic] up driving her out of her own home.
01:09.6
01:19.2
This has been reported quite a bit through the gaming media, as well as in other mainstream sources like the L.A. Times and the UK's Telegraph.
01:19.9
01:23.4
Esparza: I'm very familiar with the case - or with the incident.
01:23.5
01:29.0
There's nothing- there's no record of anything occuring on the 28th of August.
01:29.1
01:32.3
I've been reach her for the past two days.
01:32.4
01:34.3
Aurini: So she n-
01:34.4
01:40.8
Esparza: So, if you have a way to contact this person and ask them for a case number, we would appreciate that.
01:41.1
01:46.2
There's no record from our dispatch center, that I called and asked.
01:46.7
01:49.5
There's no record of any report being taken.
01:50.2
01:58.1
I saw her tweet that says "authorities." I need to make sure that she reported to the San Francisco police and how she did it, because there's no record.
01:59.0
02:04.6
Aurini: Okay, thank you. I just have a couple of other questions about how you typically deal with these cases, if you don't mind.
02:06.3
02:11.4
She said that the officers told her she should stop doing her cultural commentary if she was receiving threats.
02:12.5
02:17.4
Is this the sort of thing that you would say to a victim of harassment?
02:18.0
02:24.7
Esparza: No, but that's hearsay, so it's third-party information, so I'm not going to speculate on whether or not that was said.
02:24.8
02:28.2
But, we wouldn't say that to someone who's filing a report.
02:28.3
02:33.9
Aurini: Would that possibly be disciplinary action if an officer were to say such a thing?
02:34.0
02:38.2
Esparza: We're not going to talk about hypothetical situations because it's hearsay.
02:38.3
02:39.4
Aurini: Understood.
02:39.5
02:47.2
Esparza: There's no record of that incident occurring, and so I'm not going to speculate. And therefore, it's inapproprate to make comments on that.
02:47.3
02:49.0
Aurini: Understood.
02:49.1
02:53.3
I have some colleagues that have received harassment in other districts,
02:53.4
03:03.8
and the police there recommended that they not respond to it or discuss it online once the investigation has begun.
03:03.9
03:11.5
Is that your department's policy, and if not, what advice would you give to somebody that was receiving threats?
03:11.6
03:21.9
Esparza: Well, if someone receives a threat - we're talking specifically online or via text messaging or Twitter and e-mails, that type of stuff -
03:22.0
03:33.4
it's important to document it. So they should somehow save either a text message or an e-mail or a tweet.
03:33.5
03:40.4
If they can capture that and bring it to the police station as evidence, that would be booked.
03:40.9
03:47.8
It's very important that they document it, as long as they can do so safely.
03:47.9
03:56.8
But, it's very imporant because, again, if they don't do it and this continues, you never know what could happen, right?
03:56.9
04:08.5
So, at least document it. If the department has any leads we will do our best, because we take it seriously when someone makes threats against someone's life.
04:09.3
04:15.2
So we would ask that they file a report. Bring the evidence so we can initiate an investigation.
04:15.3
04:18.4
Aurini: Alright, and I guess just one final question.
04:18.5
04:30.6
Would your department handle online harassment, or is this the sort of thing that you would pass on to the F.B.I. or somebody else?
04:31.0
04:36.3
Esparza: Well, it certainly depends on the nature; what the threat says.
04:36.9
04:40.7
Typically, if it's just threats, our department would handle it.
04:41.1
04:52.9
If it's anything more significant, as far as maybe local domestic terorrism, that type of stuff, it would go to FBI or federal agents.
04:53.0
04:56.7
But typically, the city would handle these types of incidents.
04:56.8
05:05.3
Aurini: Okay, so if it was an online anonymous account - we don't know who the person is, they just create a fake account to send death threats -
05:05.4
05:12.2
would you possibly pass that on, because it's not a local- it's not a domestic violence thing between a local couple?
05:13.0
05:23.7
Esparza: We would certainly investigate it. If we feel that it's something that's probably on a larger scale, we would share it with our regional partners or even federal agents.
05:23.8
05:27.2
But, every case is individual and unique and different.
05:27.3
05:35.0
But, typically if it's something that seems more significant, then yes, it would be shared among our law inforcement partners.
05:35.1
05:37.3
Aurini: Okay.
05:37.6
05:43.9
You said you were trying to get a hold of Ms. Sarkeesian because you've never heard of it.
05:44.0
05:49.8
You would like the case number that she received if she reported it as she claims? That is correct?
05:51.2
06:00.8
Esparza: Right, so I do have a report where Ms. Sarkeesian was a victim of threats as well, but this was back in March of this year [2014].
06:00.9
06:09.8
So that's the only record I found, but there's nothing as of yet from August 20 or 29th.
06:10.3
06:13.5
Aurini: Okay, well I was just going to say as part of my ongoing investigation-
06:20.8
06:25.9
Esparza: Yeah, because of the thing that it says on her tweet, she reported to authorities.
06:26.3
06:33.3
But, there are multiple police agencies in San Francisco, so I want to make sure that she reported to the San Francisco Police.
06:33.7
06:43.1
And, I did call the local precinct where she lives, they don't have any records of an investigation with her name currently.
06:43.8
06:45.5
Aurini: So, this is-
06:45.6
06:50.4
Esparza: And like I said, the only thing that came up in my system was a case from March of this year.
06:50.5
06:59.2
Aurini: Okay, so you are the public representation person for the entire San Francisco area - all of the districts within?
07:00.2
07:02.6
Esparza: San Francisco Police Department, yes.
07:02.9
07:05.6
Aurini: Okay, I think that's all of my questions.
07:05.7
07:11.1
Thank you very much, you've been very informative and I hope you have a good day.
07:11.6
07:13.2
Esparza: You too, sir. Take care.
07:13.3
07:14.2
Aurini: Goodbye.
07:14.3
07:15.3
Esparza: Alright, bye.
07:19.2
07:21.1
Aurini: Well, there you have it, folks.
07:21.2
07:26.0
There was a report back in March that she was being harassased.
07:26.7
07:30.9
There has been no reports - that they are aware of - happening in August.
07:32.5
07:36.6
And, they would actually like to get a hold of her and find out about this case number.
07:37.0
07:40.7
And, they do seem to take death threats fairly seriously.
07:44.6
07:48.5
There you have it. Support us on the Sarkeesian Effect.
07:48.6
07:52.2
Okay, this just cost me some long-distance minutes, alright?
07:53.0
08:02.1
But, actually doing a documentary, there's [sic] a lot more work that we need to do. There's [sic] a lot of people we need to go talk to.
08:02.2
08:07.0
Unlike some of the prominent figures I've mentioned who've agreed to be in the documentary already,
08:07.1
08:12.6
a lot of these people are private. A lot of these people work in, for instance, game development.
08:13.0
08:22.0
And, if they simply write a blog post about this, or if they show up on my podcast talking about what they know,
08:22.1
08:29.5
then that's not an authoritative source, and that can be construed as harassment, even though it's not.
08:30.9
08:39.0
So with making the documentary, however - as an official, respected source that will go on Wikipedia, that will go on IMDb -
08:39.3
08:50.0
at this point, they can claim harassment if they are fired, because we will be investigating all of their claims as well and confirming their claims.
08:50.1
08:57.0
There were a couple of bits of this video censored, because you don't need to know where Anita lives.
08:57.1
09:00.6
That's not relevant information to this.
09:00.7
09:09.4
But the relevant information is that she apparently has not contacted the local police department.
09:11.9
09:19.0
Help us look into this more. Support our documentary.